Cleveland Browns' Quarterback Carousel Narrows to Three Contenders for 2026
The Cleveland Browns' quarterback situation has undergone a dramatic shift, evolving from a crowded field of six signal-callers in the 2025 offseason to a focused trio for 2026. This group includes two second-year players from the 2025 draft—Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel—alongside veteran Deshaun Watson, who is returning from a season-long injury. The upcoming offseason is poised to determine who emerges as the favorite to lead the team, setting the stage for an intense competition.
Shedeur Sanders Impresses with Dedication and a Symbolic Jersey Change
Shedeur Sanders has wasted no time making his mark in Cleveland, demonstrating a strong work ethic and a keen understanding of what it takes to succeed in the NFL. From meeting new head coach Todd Monken on his very first day to sending a thoughtful birthday gift—a gold horse—Sanders has shown he knows how to build relationships. His efforts have not gone unnoticed by Browns owner Jimmy Haslam, who praised the young quarterback's commitment during the NFL Owners Meetings in Phoenix.
Haslam highlighted that Sanders spent most of the winter in Cleveland, working out early and showcasing his dedication to becoming an NFL quarterback. "His body looks better," Haslam noted. "He's been working hard. It's hard for a lot of college kids to understand what it takes to play in the NFL, and particularly as a quarterback. Shedeur got an education in that, and my instincts are he'll come back ready to play." Adding to his preparation, Sanders recently switched from his rookie No. 12 jersey to No. 2, which he wore during his successful high school and college days under his father, legendary cornerback Deion Sanders. This change symbolizes his readiness to reclaim past glory.
Deshaun Watson Eyes a Fresh Start Under Offensive-Minded Coach Todd Monken
Meanwhile, Deshaun Watson is looking to rebound after being labeled a "big swing and miss" in the 2025 offseason due to his injury. Now healthy, Watson is eager to return to the gridiron and has received a vote of confidence from Haslam, who believes the veteran has a "great chance" for a "fresh start" with first-year head coach Todd Monken. Monken, who previously served as the offensive coordinator for the Lamar Jackson-led Baltimore Ravens in 2025, brings a wealth of experience working with diverse quarterbacks.
Haslam elaborated on Watson's prospects, stating, "Deshaun has a great chance, a fresh start, and an offensive-minded coach, who has in his past been able to work with all kinds of different quarterbacks and make them successful." Watson himself is in peak physical condition, with Haslam revealing that the quarterback weighs the least he has in several years and will be in Cleveland for the offseason workout program starting April 7. This sets the stage for a potential resurgence.
Todd Monken's Track Record and the Quarterback Competition Dynamics
Todd Monken's coaching career spans over three decades, including stints in both college and the NFL, and he himself was a college quarterback. His experience with various signal-callers—such as Stetson Bennett at Georgia Bulldogs, Jameis Winston with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and Baker Mayfield in Cleveland—demonstrates his ability to adapt and succeed. Bennett became a Heisman finalist and back-to-back national champion, while Winston now works under Monken's close colleague, John Harbaugh, with the New York Giants.
The Browns have struggled with quarterback stability in recent years, from trading Baker Mayfield after a playoff victory to Watson's limited play since 2022. The 2025 season saw two rookies struggling to adapt, resulting in a 5-12 record. With Watson's return, the 2026 offseason promises an open competition among Watson, Sanders, and Gabriel. This trio offers a mix of veteran leadership and youthful potential, aiming to transform Cleveland's quarterback woes into a strength.
As the Browns prepare for the 2026 season, all eyes will be on this quarterback battle. Will Shedeur Sanders' dedication and jersey change propel him to the starting role? Can Deshaun Watson capitalize on his fresh start under Monken? Only time will tell, but one thing is clear: the competition in Cleveland is heating up, and it could define the team's future success.
