In a sharp critique from Mumbai, Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut on Sunday labeled it as "unethical" that Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant accepted a welcome at the city airport from Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde. This comes at a time when the crucial case determining who controls the Shiv Sena and its symbol remains pending before the Supreme Court, a matter that has been delayed for over three and a half years.
Unprecedented Political Reception at Airport
Raut emphasized that such receptions are typically handled by the bureaucracy, including the chief secretary, rather than politicians. "Usually, the CJI is received by the bureaucracy, including the chief secretary. This time, Shinde was present at the airport. The CJI accepted a bouquet from him even though the case is pending before him in Supreme Court and has been delayed for the last three-and-a-half years," he stated. He noted that this was the first instance he had witnessed a politician welcoming the CJI at an airport, raising eyebrows about the propriety of the interaction.
Allegations of Political Motivations
Further intensifying his allegations, Raut claimed that Shinde also visited the hotel where the CJI was staying, suggesting a deeper level of engagement. "It proves once again why our case is dragging on," he remarked, implying that such interactions might influence the judicial process. Raut went on to allege that the CJI plans to enter politics, stating, "This is why he is maintaining relations with political parties." These comments highlight growing concerns about the separation of powers and judicial impartiality in high-stakes political disputes.
Criticism Extends to BJP Minister Mangal Prabhat Lodha
In a related development, Raut also targeted BJP minister Mangal Prabhat Lodha, who has proposed dropping ‘King Edward' from the name of King Edward Memorial (KEM) Hospital on grounds of nationalism. Raut questioned Lodha's consistency, pointing out his business dealings with former US President Donald Trump, who has previously threatened India. "Lodha wants to do this on grounds of nationalism. But has business dealings with US President Donald Trump who has threatened India," he said.
Call for Name Change Consistency
Raut highlighted that Lodha had renamed Lodha Tower as Trump Tower, suggesting a double standard. "First, he should change that name to Modi Tower, Thackeray Tower or Chhatrapati Shivaji Tower. Then we can talk about KEM Hospital," he argued. This critique underscores broader debates about nationalism, historical symbols, and political hypocrisy in contemporary Indian discourse.
The unfolding controversy sheds light on the intricate interplay between politics and judiciary in India, with Raut's remarks sparking discussions on ethics, pending legal cases, and the role of public figures in maintaining institutional integrity. As the Shiv Sena case continues to await resolution, such incidents may fuel further scrutiny of the processes involved.
