The Himachal Pradesh High Court has voiced significant apprehension regarding alleged safety and regulatory breaches during the recently concluded Shimla Winter Carnival. The court's concern emerged during a hearing related to a public interest litigation (PIL) petition, prompting it to seek a detailed response from the state government.
Court Questions Carnival Management and Safety
A division bench comprising Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua presided over the hearing. The bench directed the state government to clarify its stance on the reported violations. The court's intervention was triggered by information suggesting that the carnival's organization on the historic Ridge ground may have compromised public safety and flouted established norms.
The judges pointedly asked the government's counsel whether the administration had granted proper permissions for the event and if all necessary safety precautions were meticulously followed. The bench emphasized that the primary responsibility for ensuring a safe and rule-compliant event rests squarely with the district administration and the state government.
Focus on the Ridge Ground and Government's Response
The core of the court's inquiry revolves around the use of the ecologically and historically sensitive Ridge maidan for the carnival. The PIL, filed by a local resident, argues that large-scale commercial and entertainment activities at this location violate environmental guidelines and pose a threat to the area's heritage status.
During the proceedings, the government's legal representative, Additional Advocate General Shreshth Sharma, requested time to file a comprehensive status report. This report is expected to detail the permissions granted, the safety measures implemented, and the government's official position on the allegations. The court has granted this request and scheduled the next hearing for March 6, 2024.
Broader Implications and Public Safety
This judicial scrutiny highlights the ongoing tension between promoting tourism through grand events and preserving public safety, environmental integrity, and legal compliance. The Shimla Winter Carnival is a major tourist attraction, but the High Court's questions underscore that its execution must not overlook statutory responsibilities.
The court's stance sends a clear message to event organizers and authorities across Himachal Pradesh. It establishes a precedent that cultural and tourism festivals, while economically beneficial, must be conducted within a strict framework of law and safety protocols. The outcome of this case could influence the planning and permission process for all future large-scale public events in the hill state.
All eyes are now on the detailed affidavit the Himachal Pradesh government will submit. Its contents will determine whether the carnival's organization is deemed legally sound or if corrective actions and stricter oversight will be mandated for future editions.
