Calcutta High Court Grills State Over CISF Personnel Lodged in Chinese School
The Calcutta High Court has issued a sharp directive to the West Bengal government, demanding it present a concrete plan for relocating Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) personnel currently stationed at the Pei May Chinese High School in Tangra, Kolkata. This development follows a petition filed by the school management, which is urgently seeking to reclaim its premises to host Chinese New Year celebrations scheduled for February 16.
School's Temporary Agreement Turns Into 18-Month Occupancy
According to court submissions, the school authorities initially agreed to a temporary arrangement in August 2024, providing 18 rooms for two months to house CISF jawans. This was done at the request of the state's home and hill affairs department, following the deployment of these personnel at RG Kar Medical College & Hospital after a tragic rape-murder incident. However, what was meant to be a short-term solution has now stretched to over 18 months, causing significant disruption to the school's operations.
The counsel representing the school and the local Chinese community emphasized that the premises were loaned strictly on a temporary basis. They argued that the continued presence of security forces would severely impede the planned Chinese New Year festivities, a major cultural event for the community.
State's Defense and Financial Expenditure
In response, the state government contended that the CISF presence remains essential for maintaining peace and order in the Tangra area. Officials revealed that approximately Rs 42.7 lakh has been invested in renovating the school facilities to accommodate the personnel. Seeking more time, the state requested a six-month extension to identify and prepare an alternative location.
This plea, however, was met with skepticism from the bench. Justice Krishna Rao pointedly questioned the state's handling of the situation, noting discrepancies in statements made before different courts.
Judge's Stern Rebuke and Directives
During the hearing, Justice Rao did not mince words, expressing frustration over the prolonged occupancy. "What is the state doing? Where is the money going? After the term ends, the authorities are not providing any place or taking any action for them," he remarked.
The judge further highlighted what he perceived as inefficiencies, stating, "Panel advocates are more powerful than the officers. Spending only Rs 45 lakh is not enough. There is such a large complex in Salt Lake. Why aren't tents being set up there to relocate the CISF?" This critique underscores concerns about administrative delays and resource allocation.
Court's Final Order and Next Steps
Concluding the proceedings, Justice Rao directed the West Bengal government to formally inform the court of a viable alternative arrangement for the CISF personnel. The next hearing has been scheduled for February 12, just days before the Chinese New Year event, adding urgency to the state's task.
This case highlights the ongoing tension between temporary security measures and the rights of educational and cultural institutions. The outcome will likely set a precedent for how similar situations are managed in the future, balancing public safety with community needs.
