Manoj Muntashir Advocates for Mindful Speech Amid AR Rahman's Communal Bias Controversy
Lyricist Manoj Muntashir has weighed in on the ongoing debate sparked by Oscar-winning composer AR Rahman's recent comments about alleged communal bias in the Hindi film industry. In a thoughtful response, Muntashir emphasized the critical need for public figures to exercise caution and wisdom when expressing their views in the public domain.
The Context: AR Rahman's Controversial Remarks
AR Rahman stirred significant controversy after claiming in an interview with BBC Asian Network that he may have lost work opportunities over the past eight years due to a power shift within the industry and potential communal bias. The celebrated composer suggested that non-creative individuals now hold power, and whispers of communal preferences have affected his projects, though he noted it was not overtly visible to him.
Following backlash on social media, Rahman later clarified his statements, expressing deep love for India and his commitment to music that honors the nation's diversity. He described India as his inspiration and home, reaffirming his dedication to uplifting through his art.
Manoj Muntashir's Perspective on Celebrity Responsibility
In an interview with India Today, Manoj Muntashir, who has himself faced online trolling for his statements, drew a poignant analogy between speech and water. "There is one thing common between water and speech (paani and vaani). If they cross their limits, the result is the same — destruction," he stated.
Muntashir elaborated that when public figures speak, their words carry immense weight and can influence many listeners. "When you speak as a public figure and many people listen to you — I am also talking about Mithoon and others — it becomes our collective responsibility," he explained. He urged celebrities to reflect deeply before speaking, considering whether their words might impact the social fabric or convey unintended messages.
"We need to weigh our words carefully and speak with wisdom. That's all I want to say," Muntashir concluded, highlighting the importance of thoughtful communication in maintaining harmony.
The Intersection of Art and Politics
Delving further, Muntashir addressed the notion of being apolitical, asserting that complete separation from politics is impossible. "Anyone who says, 'I am apolitical,' is lying. If you are 18 years old and you have voted — and even if you have chosen NOTA — you have still taken a position. So no, you cannot remain apolitical," he argued.
He defended his own statements, noting that while some have been misunderstood or misquoted, he stands by them with full responsibility. "I believe that whatever has happened to me, I have never regretted a single statement I have made," Muntashir affirmed, emphasizing personal conviction in public discourse.
Mithoon's Balanced View and Industry Reactions
In contrast, composer Mithoon chose to distance himself from the controversy, offering a more balanced perspective. He acknowledged Rahman's right to express his feelings but highlighted the widespread admiration for the composer across cultures and faiths in India.
"What Rahman sir said — he has the right to express what he felt. But from my perspective as an audience member, I think this country has celebrated him beyond everything," Mithoon remarked. He pointed out that respect for Rahman transcends caste, color, and creed within the industry, underscoring India's enduring love for the musician as non-debatable.
This controversy has ignited discussions among celebrities and fans alike, with many sharing divergent views on the issues of bias, power dynamics, and freedom of expression in Bollywood. As the debate continues, Muntashir's call for mindful speech serves as a reminder of the influential role public figures play in shaping societal narratives.
