In a recent discussion that has set the MMA community abuzz, renowned podcaster and commentator Joe Rogan presented a compelling case for why the current lightweight champion, Islam Makhachev, poses an even greater threat than his legendary predecessor, Khabib Nurmagomedov. While acknowledging Khabib's iconic status, Rogan pointed to Makhachev's more versatile arsenal as the key differentiator.
Rogan's Breakdown: A More Complete Fighter
Speaking on episode #172 of the JRE MMA Show with Gable Steveson, Rogan delved deep into the fighting styles of the two Dagestani phenoms. He expressed immense respect for Khabib Nurmagomedov, describing his greatness as built upon unmatched pressure, control, and relentless wrestling. Rogan firmly placed Nurmagomedov among the absolute best fighters in UFC history.
However, Rogan argued that Islam Makhachev has evolved the blueprint. "Makhachev stands apart because of his striking ability," Rogan explained. He noted that while Khabib was solid on the feet, he rarely sought flashy knockouts, relying on his ground dominance. In contrast, Makhachev has demonstrated he can end fights standing up against elite competition.
Rogan specifically highlighted Makhachev's devastating head-kick knockout of Alexander Volkanovski as a weapon never seen in Khabib's arsenal. This striking prowess, combined with his elite grappling, creates a fighter who is dangerous in every phase of the game.
The Verdict: A Higher Level of Danger
Joe Rogan's analysis concluded that Makhachev operates at a higher overall level. "He can finish fights in every possible way," Rogan stated. According to him, Makhachev's toolkit includes knockout power on the feet, ground-and-pound finishes, submission skills, and dominant wrestling. Rogan also emphasized that Makhachev's physical size for the lightweight division makes him an even more formidable force at 155 pounds.
This perspective has ignited fresh debates among fans, many of whom consider Khabib Nurmagomedov the greatest of all time. Rogan's comments challenge that notion by suggesting Makhachev's style is more multidimensional and thus a bigger threat to any opponent.
Makhachev's Response and Current Landscape
Away from Rogan's commentary, Islam Makhachev has been making headlines for other reasons. He recently responded calmly to continued verbal jabs from featherweight champion Ilia Topuria, who has been targeting both Makhachev and Nurmagomedov. Makhachev suggested he senses resentment from Topuria and indicated that any tension could be settled in the cage in the future.
On the fighting front, Makhachev recently solidified his dominance by capturing the welterweight title with a strong victory over Jack Della Maddalena at UFC 322. This move up in weight class further showcased his adaptability and skill. Meanwhile, Ilia Topuria, who won the lightweight belt by knocking out Charles Oliveira at UFC 317, is currently taking time away from the sport.
Joe Rogan's analysis underscores a significant shift in the perception of Dagestani dominance in the UFC. While Khabib Nurmagomedov's legacy is untouchable, Islam Makhachev is carving his own path by adding a potent striking dimension to the famed grappling foundation, making him, in Rogan's view, the more complete and dangerous fighter today.
