MS Dhoni Opens Up on Commentary Hesitation: The Art of Description vs. Criticism
Mahendra Singh Dhoni, the legendary cricketer whose insights into the game are widely revered, has shed light on why he has never ventured into the commentary box, unlike other cricketing greats such as Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri. In a candid conversation with commentator Jatin Sapru, Dhoni revealed the complexities and personal challenges that keep him away from this aspect of the sport.
The Delicate Balance of Commentary
Dhoni emphasized that commentary is a demanding task, requiring a nuanced approach. "It's a very difficult thing, you know. Commentary is very difficult," he stated. He pointed out that there is a "very fine line" between merely describing the game and inadvertently slipping into criticism of the players on the field. This thin boundary, according to Dhoni, is often crossed without realization, making it a tricky domain to navigate.
He elaborated on his preference for staying on the side of pure description. "I would always prefer to be on the side where you are simply describing the game," Dhoni said. However, he acknowledged that pointing out flaws is sometimes necessary, but it must be done with tact. "How you put it is an art. How do you put it forward politely so that nobody feels targeted, but the message still gets across?" he questioned, highlighting the skill needed to address team issues without causing offense.
Statistics and Personal Communication Hurdles
Beyond the ethical considerations, Dhoni admitted to another significant barrier: his struggle with statistics. He noted that while commentators often receive extensive data from support teams, he finds this aspect challenging. "I'm just not good with stats. If you ask me about my own stats, I'll be lost!" he confessed. He praised those who excel in this area, calling them "brilliant at commentary" for their ability to weave detailed statistics into their analysis.
Adding a personal touch, Dhoni shared his discomfort with phone conversations. "I also know one thing I'm terrible at: answering the phone," he revealed. He described himself as someone who prefers face-to-face interactions, finding phone calls awkward due to the lack of visual cues. "I'm a very awkward guy when it comes to speaking on the phone," he said, joking that he would rather visit Japan than engage in such communication.
Reflecting on the evolution of mobile phones, Dhoni humorously remarked, "When mobile phones first came out, they were for the benefit of the person who owned them. Now, your mobile phone is for everyone else's benefit." This insight underscores his preference for personal connections over digital interactions.
Dhoni's Legacy and Future in Cricket
Despite his retirement from international cricket, Dhoni continues to be a pivotal figure in the Indian Premier League with Chennai Super Kings. His decision to avoid commentary stems from a deep understanding of the game's intricacies and his own strengths and weaknesses. By choosing to focus on in-person engagements and team leadership, he maintains his unique impact on cricket without venturing into areas where he feels less confident.
This revelation adds another layer to Dhoni's persona, showcasing his humility and self-awareness. It resonates with fans and aspiring commentators alike, emphasizing that even legends have their boundaries and preferences in how they contribute to the sport they love.
