West Indies all-rounder and former captain Jason Holder has voiced strong criticism of the escalating tensions between India and Pakistan in cricket, specifically referencing the dramatic events that followed the Asia Cup 2025 final. Holder expressed his disappointment with what he termed excessive "beef" and on-field theatrics, urging for the sport to become a unifying force.
Holder's Disappointment with Trophy Snub
The immediate trigger for Holder's comments was the post-final ceremony of the Asia Cup 2025. India defeated Pakistan by five wickets in the final to lift the trophy, yet the victory was overshadowed by a diplomatic incident. Indian players opted not to collect the trophy from Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) chairman Mohsin Naqvi, against the backdrop of the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor.
This led to Naqvi taking the trophy back, meaning the winning Indian team returned home without the physical trophy. Speaking candidly on the Willow by Cricbuzz podcast, Holder did not mince his words. "I don’t like the India–Pakistan beef. I saw India win the Asia Cup and they didn’t go to accept the trophy. It’s just too much, man," he stated.
A Broader Critique of Politics in Cricket
Holder then expanded his view to address the wider political and ownership issues affecting the game, particularly the isolation of Pakistani cricketers in global T20 leagues. He pointed out the restrictive dynamics created by franchise ownership.
"Certain Pakistanis can’t be involved in certain teams because they’re owned by Indian owners. It’s just sad, man," Holder added, highlighting a long-standing point of contention in the cricket world where Pakistani players are absent from the Indian Premier League (IPL) and face limited opportunities in other leagues with Indian stakeholders.
A Plea for Unity and Positive Influence
The seasoned cricketer emphasized the influential role top athletes play and called for them to lead by example. "If you’re inspiring a generation and inspiring the world, then we have to find a way to come together," Holder asserted.
While acknowledging the deep-rooted political history between the two nations, he firmly believes cricket can be a catalyst for change. "I understand how big this rivalry is off the field," he noted. "But if change is going to happen, it can start on the cricket field. A way to soften things is by India and Pakistan coming together through sport."
Holder sees the potential for this unity to extend beyond the boundary ropes. "If it’s possible at a sporting level, maybe it becomes possible in everyday life too," he said. "Stopping the fighting and tension would be huge." He also spoke about the cultural responsibility of sports heroes, noting the trickle-down effect their behavior has on fans.
Concluding with a heartfelt appeal, Holder expressed his respect for both nations and the spirit of cricket. "They’re beautiful countries with incredible people and cultures. That’s why moments like this hurt everyone who loves cricket," he said. "We talk about unity and growing the game. So let’s practise what we preach — bring cricket together and build healthier relationships."
The Asia Cup 2025 featured three high-octane clashes between the two sides, including the final, keeping the intense rivalry in the global spotlight. With no bilateral cricket between India and Pakistan for several years, ICC and ACC events remain the sole stage for this iconic contest.
