Australian cricket legend Matthew Hayden has launched a scathing attack on the team's batting coach, Michael di Venuto, following Australia's disappointing batting performances in the fourth Ashes Test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG).
Hayden's Unacceptable Verdict on Batting Collapse
Speaking on the All Over Bar The Cricket podcast on December 30, 2025, Hayden did not mince his words. He labelled the team's scorecard as "unacceptable", regardless of the challenging pitch conditions with 50 millimetres of grass.
"You need to be better than that," Hayden fumed. He pointed out that key batters like Travis Head, Jake Weatherald, Marnus Labuschagne, Usman Khawaja, Alex Carey, and Cameron Green appeared lost in their basic techniques. Hayden noted a stark contrast, suggesting that the Australian bowlers looked more technically proficient than the batters.
A Critique of Coaching, Not the Person
Hayden was careful to clarify that his criticism was professional, not personal. "I'm not a fan of him. It's not a personal thing," he stated regarding di Venuto. The former opener argued that the batting influence within the team had failed to develop players technically for a long time, not just on green pitches but also in subcontinent conditions like Delhi.
He emphasised the need for accountability from the coaching staff. "At some point, you have to take accountability," Hayden said, criticising what he saw as a one-dimensional approach to different pitches.
Defence and Sympathy for the Coach
However, star batter Steve Smith has staunchly defended di Venuto. In June, Smith said he was "completely against" any criticism of 'Diva', praising his hard work and deep knowledge of batting.
Former Test opener Greg Blewett also sympathised with the batting coach's position. Blewett suggested that a coach can only provide information and technical advice—like pointing out Labuschagne's overly front-on stance—but it is ultimately up to the player to implement changes.
Hayden also singled out individual batters, comparing Marnus Labuschagne unfavourably to greats like Ricky Ponting for giving his wicket away at number three. The criticism highlights the intense scrutiny on the Australian batting unit as they reflect on their Ashes campaign.
