The Supreme Court on Friday allowed wrestler Vinesh Phogat to participate in the selection trials for the 2026 Asian Games, while expressing strong disapproval of the Delhi High Court's handling of the case. However, the court also questioned the decorated athlete for not making herself available for a mandatory doping test.
Court's Observations
A bench comprising Justices P S Narasimha and Alok Aradhe noted that any delay in deciding the issue would have jeopardized Phogat's chance to take part in Saturday's trials. Taking into account her significant contributions to Indian sports, having represented the country at multiple international platforms, including three Olympics, the bench allowed her to proceed with the trials despite objections raised by the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI).
The bench emphasized that Phogat is not an ordinary athlete, as she has made the nation proud through her achievements. However, it also made it clear that rules must be followed by everyone. The court noted that she did not appear for the doping test, and her explanation that she, being a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA), was busy with assembly proceedings, was not deemed satisfactory.
Concerns Over Doping Test
The court remarked, "What is concerning is that when the International Testing Agency's test is missed, it has a logical consequence, because Indian sports is integrally connected to world sports. If some kind of disqualification appears at the global level, it reflects on India. You did not give the whereabouts for the doping test and missed the first doping test."
The bench also expressed reservations about the approach adopted by the High Court in granting relief to the wrestler. "The way the High Court handled the case is disturbing. The constitutional court should act responsibly as these are national and international sporting events," the bench said.
Background of the Case
The court was hearing an appeal filed by the WFI challenging the High Court's order that allowed Phogat to compete in the trials. Senior advocate Madhavi Divan, representing Phogat, submitted that women athletes often face problems arising out of pregnancy and stated that she was not seeking any relaxation but merely an opportunity to participate in the trials.
The bench indicated that it may not be correct to withdraw the participation allowed by the High Court. It further noted that it would not be good for the country if Phogat is disqualified from games due to non-compliance with rules, and that this factor should also be considered while deciding the controversy.
Stay updated with IPL Live Score and the latest IPL news on Times of India. Follow the IPL schedule and track the race for the IPL Orange Cap and Purple Cap.
