Andhra Pradesh High Court Criticizes VMC's E-Tender Process for Meat and Fish Stalls
The Andhra Pradesh High Court on Friday strongly reprimanded officials of the Vijayawada Municipal Corporation (VMC) for adopting an e-tender route for the allotment of meat and fish stalls in the Mahanti Market. Justice Gannamaneni Ramakrishna Prasad expressed serious concerns about the practicality of this digital approach for traditional vendors.
Court Questions Digital Accessibility for Traditional Vendors
During the hearing, Justice Prasad questioned how officials could expect fish sellers to navigate the complex process of uploading documents required for the e-tender. The judge specifically pointed out that most meat and fish sellers may have little to no knowledge of how computers work, making it nearly impossible for them to access information and participate effectively in the tendering process.
The case was brought before the court by Harimanikyam Shankar Rao, a fish seller who challenged the e-tender notification issued on January 6. Rao contended that the officials had issued the notification without adequate publicity and that it was published only in English in vernacular newspapers, further limiting accessibility for local vendors.
Contrasting Arguments from VMC and Judicial Observations
In response, the standing council for VMC informed the High Court that they had conducted an awareness drive to educate vendors about the e-tender process. However, Justice Prasad remained unconvinced, criticizing officials for making decisions from air-conditioned rooms while completely ignoring ground-level realities.
The judge emphasized that the digital divide poses a significant barrier for traditional vendors who rely on daily market operations for their livelihood. By suspending the e-tender notification, the court highlighted the need for more inclusive and practical approaches to public tenders that consider the capabilities and circumstances of all stakeholders.
Court Directs VMC to File Counter Affidavit
Justice Prasad directed the Vijayawada Municipal Corporation to file a counter affidavit addressing the concerns raised about the e-tender process. The court has scheduled the matter for further hearing on March 3, giving VMC officials time to respond to the judicial observations and potentially revise their approach.
This case underscores broader issues of digital inclusion in governmental processes, particularly when they affect vulnerable communities with limited technological access. The court's intervention serves as a reminder that modernization efforts must be balanced with considerations of equity and practical implementation.
