In a stunning move that has sent shockwaves through Bachelor Nation, producers have selected Taylor Frankie Paul, the breakout star from 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives', as the next lead for 'The Bachelorette' Season 22. The announcement, which came as a complete surprise to fans and alumni alike, marks a dramatic departure from the franchise's usual casting choices.
Kelsey Anderson's Candid Reaction to the Surprise Announcement
The news left even recent fan favourites reeling. Kelsey Anderson, who found love with Joey Graziadei on Season 28 of 'The Bachelor', was among those utterly caught off guard. Speaking at an industry event in January, Anderson revealed her genuine shock in an interview with StyleCaster. "I was utterly surprised," she confessed, adding, "I thought that 'The Bachelorette' wasn't coming back this season, I thought that they were only gonna do 'The Bachelor'. That's what I heard."
Anderson's initial disbelief mirrored the online frenzy. After a string of conventional 'Bachelor' seasons, the choice of Taylor Frankie Paul—a personality from outside the traditional Bachelor circle—was a true curveball. Anderson recalled how speculation began swirling the night before the official reveal, with someone tipping her off about Paul's potential casting.
From Shock to Support: A Fan's Encouragement
However, Kelsey Anderson's reaction quickly evolved from surprise to wholehearted support. A longtime admirer of Taylor Frankie Paul, Anderson praised her sense of humour and authentic online presence. "To me it is, I'm excited!" she declared enthusiastically. "I love Mormon Wives! I love Taylor, she's always been so kind to me."
Anderson's support wasn't merely superficial. She expressed a sincere willingness to guide Paul through the unique experience, stating, "I'm excited to support her on her journey and whatever she needs." This genuine, encouraging energy resonated deeply with fans, who appreciated that her comments went beyond a polite soundbite.
In a charming behind-the-scenes moment, Anderson also shared her fiancé Joey Graziadei's laid-back response to the news, which was essentially no reaction at all—a detail that made her laugh and highlighted the relatable, everyday dynamics between the reality stars.
What This Means for the Future of The Bachelorette
With 'The Bachelorette' set to return in March 2026, Kelsey Anderson's blend of shock, admiration, and encouragement perfectly captures the current mood of the fanbase. Taylor Frankie Paul's upcoming season is poised to break the mould, promising a fresh and unconventional narrative that has already ignited widespread conversation.
This unexpected casting choice signals a potential new direction for the long-running franchise, aiming to captivate audiences with a lead whose background and personality differ markedly from previous seasons. If the reactions from Anderson and the broader Bachelor Nation are any indication, this is one chapter in the franchise's history that viewers are eagerly awaiting.
