Clay Aiken Recalls Simon Cowell Calling Him 'Ugly' on American Idol
Clay Aiken Recalls Simon Cowell Calling Him 'Ugly'

Clay Aiken has revisited his contentious relationship with Simon Cowell, decades after finishing as the runner-up on the second season of 'American Idol.' The 47-year-old singer recalled the criticism he received from the reality show mogul, who allegedly made a snide remark about his appearance when Aiken became a pop icon.

Clay Aiken Remembers Being Called 'Ugly' by Simon Cowell

Aiken, whose debut album went multi-platinum, remembered that Simon Cowell stated he did not look great but had a good voice. When asked whether the reality show judge's method of comments actually works for the show, Clay Aiken responded in an interview with TV Insider, 'He called me ugly. Is that what you're saying?' Furthermore, the 'Rewind' singer explained that Cowell came from the world of entertainment, 'Simon came from a world where it was all about the image, not necessarily looks. It was all about the image. In my audition, he said that I didn't look like a pop star, but that I had a great voice.'

Debate Over Looks vs. Talent in 2003

Speaking about 2003, Clay Aiken expressed that there was a great dilemma at the time, whether the country was going to vote for contestants who looked like pop stars or who sang better. Naming the participants who were the Top 12 of Season 2, the singer stated, 'Carmen Rasmusen – gorgeous! Trenyce, gorgeous! Kimberly Caldwell, gorgeous! And then you had me, and well, Ruben, who was a big guy.'

Wide Pickt banner — collaborative shopping lists app for Telegram, phone mockup with grocery list

About Clay Aiken's 'American Idol' Season

Commenting on the warmth between the judges and contestants, Aiken shared that Simon Cowell was always supportive and gave a hug after someone got cut. In 'American Idol Season 2,' Ruben Studdard took the title home on the show that garnered millions of views. However, Clay Aiken came in a close second after getting consistent votes throughout the season.

The TOI Entertainment Desk is a dynamic and dedicated team of journalists, working tirelessly to bring the pulse of the entertainment world straight to the readers of The Times of India. No red carpet goes unrolled, no stage goes dark - our team spans the globe, bringing you the latest scoops and insider insights from Bollywood to Hollywood, and every entertainment hotspot in between. We don't just report; we tell tales of stardom and stories untold. Whether it's the rise of a new sensation or the seasoned journey of an industry veteran, the TOI Entertainment Desk is your front-row seat to the fascinating narratives that shape the entertainment landscape. Beyond the breaking news, we present a celebration of culture. We explore the intersections of entertainment with society, politics, and everyday life.

Pickt after-article banner — collaborative shopping lists app with family illustration