In the world of celebrity splits, tales of dramatic texts and public feuds often dominate the headlines. However, actress and singer AJ Michalka has recently shared a refreshingly different story about the end of her teenage romance with pop star Joe Jonas. Contrary to popular belief and internet speculation, their parting was a mature and mutual decision handled over a phone call.
The Truth Behind the Split: A Respectful Phone Call
Appearing on the 'Podcrushed' podcast, AJ Michalka decided to clarify the long-standing rumours about her breakup with Joe Jonas. For years, fans had assumed the split was messy, perhaps involving a text message or a voicemail, drawing parallels to other high-profile Jonas breakups. Michalka firmly dispelled these myths.
She explained that their relationship did not end via text. "We didn't break up over text—it was over a phone call," she stated. Emphasising the nature of their conversation, she described it as gentle and respectful. Despite their young age at the time, both sensed it was the right step. "It was sweet, and I think it was mutual," AJ recalled. They were two teenagers with burgeoning careers and hectic schedules, and a phone conversation felt like the most sensible and kind way to conclude their chapter.
A Look Back at a Disney-Era Teen Romance
The romance between AJ Michalka and Joe Jonas blossomed in 2006, a quintessential Disney Channel era. AJ and her sister Aly, performing as the duo Aly & AJ, were opening for the Jonas Brothers on tour. Amidst the chaos of backstage moments and long bus journeys, AJ and Joe, both just 15 years old, developed a connection.
Reflecting on those days, AJ characterised their time together as sweet and innocent, filled with the awkwardness and excitement of first love. Their relationship lasted for nearly a year, a significant period during their adolescent years, and was built on shared experiences from life on the road. They remain etched in fans' memories as one of the iconic young couples from that pop culture period.
Life Paths After the Breakup
Following their split, Joe Jonas's dating life remained in the spotlight, with notable relationships including one with Taylor Swift. He later married actress Sophie Turner, with whom he shares two children, though they have since separated. AJ Michalka continued to focus on her music and acting career. She has been in a relationship with actor Josh Pence since 2017.
Nearly two decades later, AJ and Joe have maintained a cordial relationship. In a 2025 interview with People magazine, AJ mentioned reconnecting with Joe for a performance, describing it as "refreshing" to see the kind and hard-working man he had become.
AJ Michalka's recollection presents a breakup narrative that starkly contrasts with the dramatic stories often associated with celebrity splits. It was a scenario where two young people liked each other but chose to part ways amicably when their paths diverged. This honesty even extends to her music; while the hit "Potential Breakup Song" was not about Joe, she has admitted that another track, "Flattery," was inspired by their time together—a candid revelation that has resonated with listeners.
