Social media platforms are buzzing with unconfirmed rumors that Palash Muchhal, the fiancé of Indian cricket star Smriti Mandhana, has been involved in an extramarital affair. The allegations emerged through screenshots circulating on Reddit and Instagram that supposedly show private conversations between Muchhal and a woman named Mary D'Costa.
What The Viral Screenshots Reveal
The controversial screenshots, which haven't been verified by either party involved, depict Instagram direct messages where a person alleged to be Palash Muchhal is seen flirting extensively with Mary D'Costa. The exchanges show him inviting her for various activities including swimming sessions, spa outings, and early morning walks at Versova beach.
More damagingly, the chats include conversations where the alleged sender complains about his long-distance relationship, describing it as problematic and mentioning that they meet only once every three to five months. These comments have raised eyebrows among fans given Muchhal's engagement to the Indian cricket vice-captain.
ChatGPT's Technical Analysis of The Evidence
When asked to examine the authenticity of these viral screenshots, ChatGPT provided a detailed technical and behavioral analysis while emphasizing that this doesn't constitute a verdict since neither Mandhana nor Muchhal has confirmed the allegations.
Reasons Why The Screenshots Could Be Authentic
According to the AI analysis, several technical aspects suggest the screenshots might be genuine. The Instagram DM layout perfectly matches the current design, including accurate fonts, timestamps, reaction icons, and other interface elements without any visible editing glitches typically found in manipulated images.
The conversation flow appears natural and unscripted, featuring casual language patterns, occasional typos, emotional tone variations, and appropriate use of emojis. Such organic dialogue is notoriously difficult to fabricate convincingly.
The screenshots maintain consistency across multiple pages, repeatedly referencing specific locations like Versova Beach, Silver Beach, and recurring themes such as spa plans and complaints about long-distance relationship challenges.
Message stacking and emoji reactions display technical accuracy that suggests they weren't simply copy-pasted from other sources, adding to their potential credibility.
Reasons Why The Screenshots Could Be Fabricated
However, ChatGPT also identified several red flags suggesting the screenshots might not be authentic. The Instagram account marydcosta_ belongs to an unverified individual who isn't a public figure, making it impossible to verify her credibility or even confirm her existence.
The evidence consists only of still images rather than screen recordings, which would provide stronger proof since photos are relatively easier to edit compared to videos.
The chats display only one person's perspective, meaning anyone could theoretically create a mocked conversation on their own device without actual participation from the other party.
ChatGPT also questioned the timing of the leak, noting that the screenshots surfaced conveniently after the wedding postponement, potentially amplifying public drama in a pattern commonly observed in manufactured controversies.
Ethical and Legal Implications
The AI analysis concluded with an important ethical consideration, stating that even if the screenshots are authentic, leaking private conversations without consent constitutes a privacy violation. Such materials don't qualify as legal proof of infidelity and certainly don't justify harassment against any individuals involved in the situation.
As the rumors continue to circulate, fans and observers await an official statement from either Palash Muchhal or Smriti Mandhana regarding these serious allegations that have captured social media attention across India.
