Bollywood Figures Respond to AR Rahman's Communal Bias Claim
Music legend AR Rahman recently sparked a debate in Bollywood. He suggested that communal factors might explain why he receives less work now. This comment has drawn reactions from several industry veterans.
Javed Akhtar Sees No Communal Element
Veteran lyricist Javed Akhtar firmly dismissed the idea of communal bias. He shared his views in a conversation with IANS. Akhtar stated he has never felt such an element exists in the film industry.
"I meet many people in Mumbai, and they have great respect for him," Akhtar said. He proposed alternative reasons for Rahman's reduced projects.
Akhtar believes producers might assume Rahman is too busy with international commitments. He also noted that smaller producers could feel hesitant to approach such a major personality. "But I don't believe there is any communal element in this," Akhtar emphasized. He expressed confidence that Rahman will continue to get work.
Shaan Points to Industry Superstars
Singer Shaan also addressed the issue. He shared that he himself experiences periods without work. Shaan does not view this as a personal or communal matter.
"Everyone has their own preferences, and it's not in our hands how much work we get," he explained. Shaan praised Rahman's unique talent and dedication to every project.
On the question of communal bias, Shaan offered a compelling counterpoint. "If it did, then even our three superstars of the last 30 years, who also belong to minority communities, would not have continued to grow," he argued. He was presumably referring to Shah Rukh Khan, Salman Khan, and Aamir Khan. Shaan stressed that good work and quality music should be the focus, not overthinking these issues.
Other Voices Weigh In
Music composer Shankar Mahadevan highlighted structural problems within the industry. He told IANS that decision-makers are often not musical professionals. This disconnect can affect which compositions get released.
Singer Anup Jalota echoed the supportive sentiments. "This is absolutely not true," he said regarding any bias against Rahman. Jalota praised Rahman's immense achievements and the widespread respect he commands.
Rahman's Original Comments
The discussion began after AR Rahman's interview with BBC Asian Network. He mentioned receiving less work over the past eight years. Rahman speculated that a power shift in the industry, possibly involving communal elements, could be a factor. However, he clarified he has not faced direct discrimination.
"Maybe I never get to know of this, maybe it was concealed but I didn't feel any of this," Rahman stated. He expressed a philosophical attitude, preferring to let work come to him based on his sincerity and merit.
The responses from Akhtar, Shaan, and others show a complex industry landscape. They acknowledge challenges like shifting power dynamics and personal preferences. Yet, they collectively reject the notion that communal bias is driving work decisions for a talent like AR Rahman.
